I am currently evaluating an upgrade from xunit v2 to xunit v3.

So far everything looks good, but NCrunch does not discover the tests anymore.

The reason is that all our test classes are public, but our methods are private. Dont ask why, it is a coding convention where I work.

With v2 NCrunch discovers all tests, with v3 none are found.

It is no changed behavior in v3, cause when I do a "dotnet test" all tests work. When I make a method public NCrunch also works.

With more than 20k tests I dont want to look at every class.

I guess there is nothing else I can do besides waiting for a new version?

Wow, that was fast. I hope it wasnt more work than just some different BindingFlags. It works like charm. Thanks.

I know, I am not a big fan of this design, but it has been done like this for ages in the company I work for.

The problem is that there is running some kind of code analysis in the background enforcing rulesets for public methods. The rulesets for test methods vary a lot from these. So by making the methods private, the problem was solved.

We both now that the better solution would have been to make the analysis aware of tests and enforce a different ruleset for tests, but 8 years and 20k tests later this is hard to change now.